The village idiot, stutter-toed, shock-eyed, baby-faced, would rent this film on the plot summary alone, so it is to that end which I will attend. (The village idiot is a genius).
The hard-working garbage-man, Simon Grim (the hipster-sexy James Urbaniak) is one of those lonely souls who trudges to work with a lunchbox and the requisite Budweiser, just, really, to avoid coming home. The home to which he does, eventually, everyday, come, houses a couch cradling his sprawling, depressed mother (Maria Porte), and a closed door, behind which the moanful groans of his slutty sister (the perfect Parker Posy) as she entertains another male friend.
The sitcom of Fool’s life jumps the shark when he rents out the basement room to ex-con Henry Fool (Thomas Jay Ryan), who turns everything honky-tonky! Gobbeldy-goo! Henry dons a goatee, a woolen vest, and has literary ambitions—he’s a complete alien to this one-horse, garbage-factory town. Nestled by the woodstove, the cracked volumes of his grand
Confessions speak to Grim of an otherworldly genius, but the texts remain sacrosanct, and frustrated by Fool's secret, the simple garbageman is inspired to create a work of his own to harbor from Henry's penetrating stare. Pulling an all nighter through two ballpoints and a grade-school Composition notebook, Grim's final book-length “POEM” is picked over by a condescending Henry Fool, who’s got no incentive to like the stuff.
Still, he’s moved to tears, and tears through the rest of the volume. As does Posey. As do the customers of the local 7-11, where Fool posts a single page for community perusal. A woman sings for the first time in twenty years, the high school newspaper enters court proceedings to defend their publication of the “lurid filth.” Like the warbling voices of Charlie Brown’s teachstaff, Grim's “POEM” retains its draw simply because we never get to read it. Described over and over again as “the most beautiful,” “the most life-changing,” “the most perfect” work of literature ever conceived, as the only possible description of our present culture, there’s no way Hal Hartley can show us this. Grim's poem is beautiful both because we cannot see it, and because the film presumes a world where such a document could exist.
Today, it’s too easy to blame failure on the plethora of other successes. That ol’ Harold Bloom schlock about the anxiety of genius, which is true, in a sense, seems to become less and less true as more and more absolute crap hits the airwaves. It is easy to feel—no, let me rephrase—Easy for people like
me to feel as though nothing we could ever write could make any impact.
Fool is a film which vigorously denies this anxiety, which shows a world crumble around a work of art, which shows how one Composition notebook can change a life—Grim moves out of the dump, beds a lit agent, and lives a snarky Greenwich village life as different as it could be from the shared future of Posey and Henry Fool, whose love has burned in the same flame which caught
Confessions on its final page.
My god, this is a good movie. Not only because it’s the sort of plot failing writers (read: bloggers) swoon over, but because the film itself is gorgeous—keeping the camera long on scenes of lameness, cutting quickly over jarring dialogue, pointing out to us the landmarks (Budweiser can, bathrobe) that mark out a territory in which a heady garbageman could really compose a final opus.
A good poem, I have been told, should make you suck in your breath at the last line. A good movie is the same.