NOT A MOVIE
Believing their patriarch, George Sr., to be dead, the dysfunctional Bluth family at the core of the Fox sitcom Arrested Development, holds a wake. “Wow. He’s really gone,” says George-Michael, the youngest Bluth, when called upon to speak. “If he was here right now, I would probably tell him that it all worked out. And that um, I’ll be bringing you some salmon rolls right away. In heaven.” The show’s jerky, hand-held camera cuts to the attic where George-Michael has stowed his grandfather, who is enjoying his own funeral like a curious Tom Sawyer. “Goddammit,” he says as he peeks through the air-vent, “How many times I gotta tell this kid, chicken wings?”
Like George Sr., the sitcom Arrested Development both is and isn’t dead. On November 10, Fox swashbucklers announced they would cut back the number of episodes ordered without officially canceling the show—encouraging Arrested’s producers to shop to other networks. Rumors of buy-outs abound (Showtime, FX) but the general buzz agrees that the eight episodes to air starting December fifth are no better than a deathbed.
With a paltry audience of four million, Arrested Development could be treated as just another sitcom that will die quietly unwatched. But the show has garnered such unprecedented critical acclaim—top 10 lists, Emmys, SAG awards, a Golden Globe—that its end is being protested with petitions and op-eds. One militant fan-group is even shipping bananas to Fox, a snarky reference to the frozen banana stand operated by the Bluth family.
So why the ratings? First, the show is basically un-marketed. Second, it is too hard to jump into—the plot builds like a serial novel instead of supplying story-lines like lozenges, to be swallowed whole. Third, the humor is too dry and witty, too intelligent: “America is stupid,” said one freshman, “And it’s a show for smart people.”
Such explains why Yale is one of the nerdy strongholds where Arrested’s passing will be most mourned. At a Masters Tea this October, a writer for the TV series Penn & Teller: Bullshit!, asked his audience if they had ever seen his show. Of the forty wannabe-TV writers, perhaps three had seen a single episode. Incredulous, he asked: “What shows do you watch, then?” There was really only one reply: “Arrested Development?” Yale’s Facebook Group, “Arrested Development Devotion” (A.D.D.) can claim 55 members while “The Simpsons Fan Club” has only 25.
And it’s not just for the kids. In last spring’s American Literature after 1945, professor Amy Hungerford used the phrase “Use Your Allusion” to encourage students to speak up during lecture. Hungerford was, of course, “alluding” to the name of an Arrested Development character’s magic act. “I almost cut her off to ask whether I could be Chaucer or Poe,” said Maureen (“Fuck Mountain”) Miller ’06, alluding to the episode to which Hungerford had originally alluded.
On any Monday night at 8 p.m precisely, Teddy (“Chicken Dance”) Goff SY ’07 can be found with his feet propped on his common room coffee table. Dozens of fans seated around him mouth the opening theme they’ve already memorized: “And now the story of a wealthy family who lost everything and the one son who had no choice but to keep them all together…” They are this family. And this television show may just be the glue that has “no choice but to keep them all together.”
Over in Timothy Dwight, Simon (“How much can a banana cost—10 dollars?”) Heitin ’07—a die-hard who believes “There are only two kinds of people: people who love Arrested Development and people who have never heard of it”—wrote a letter to Fox. Jonathan (“I will be my dead father’s body”) Dach’s JE ‘08’s freshman Farnam suite bonded over the first season, while over the summer Erin (“Yes, we know your name is Annyon”) Kelly PC ’07 connected with her actual family by watching the fictional one. “Once I missed an episode,” Kelly recalled, “and my dad called to remind me it was on.”
Speaking of the show’s end, Christian (“The Bullet”) Nakarado SM ’07 describes “a great darkness [that] will spread across the land, extinguishing all hope for next semester, or the rest of my life, really.” One off-campus house is hosting a mandatory-black “Wake” after December 5th’s episode. Offerings will be burnt on a makeshift raft, which will float to its death in the bathtub. There will be smoothies.
“You have to have a certain amount of intelligence,” said Michael Cera, the actor who plays George-Michael, “to decipher [the joke] and know that it's just a dirty penis joke.” Certainly, this trickery is what Yalies treasure. To loyal fans, Arrested Development can never really die. We can only hope that this coffin, like Gob Bluth’s magical one, has a trap-door.
